Understanding Natural and Artificial Flavors in Food & Beverage

Flavor is at the heart of every unforgettable dessert and beverage. From the rich, creamy notes of a vanilla custard to the bright, zesty burst of a citrus tart, the flavors we experience shape our perceptions of quality and craftsmanship. But have you ever paused to wonder what exactly gives your favorite foods and beverages their distinct taste? More importantly, does it matter whether those flavors are natural or artificial?

Today’s consumers and culinary professionals alike are becoming more curious about the origins of the ingredients they use. Questions around natural flavors versus artificial flavors are increasingly common, especially as clean-label products and transparency in food sourcing become industry standards. While both types of flavorings serve a role in dessert making, understanding the difference can empower you to make informed decisions that align with your culinary goals and values.

What Are Natural Flavors and Artificial Flavors?

It’s important to note that both natural and artificial flavors often share similar, if not identical, chemical structures. The difference lies not in how they behave or taste, but in how they are sourced. Whether a flavor molecule is extracted from a vanilla bean or synthesized in a lab, the molecular structure can be exactly the same. 

Natural Flavors: Derived from Nature

Natural flavors are extracted from real, natural sources such as plants, animals, fruits, vegetables, herbs, and spices. These flavors are developed through physical processes like distillation, fermentation, or extraction using solvents, but the base ingredients must be of natural origin. For example, a lemon natural flavor may come directly from lemon peel oils or juice concentrates, often combined with other natural substances to round out the profile. Even more complex flavors like vanilla or almond are rooted in natural components, giving them a depth and authenticity that aligns with clean-label preferences. Natural flavors typically have a shorter shelf life than their artificial counterparts and may require refrigeration to preserve their quality. However, Itaberco’s expertly formulated flavor compounds remain shelf-stable for up to two years after opening, no refrigeration required.

Artificial Flavors: Crafted in the Lab

In contrast, artificial flavors are created synthetically, using chemical compounds that are often identical or nearly identical to those found in nature. These compounds are not derived from natural sources but are instead engineered in laboratories, typically from petroleum-based materials or other non-natural origins.

Artificial dessert flavors are common in mass-produced products where consistency, cost-efficiency, and longer shelf life are prioritized. While they mimic natural flavors, their source makes them distinct from their naturally-derived counterparts.

 

Decoding Flavor Labels: The Nuances of Natural and Artificial

The term “flavor” on an ingredient label may seem simple, but it covers a range of classifications that reveal how a product is made. The “Natural” or organic labeling plays a significant role in marketing consumables. Products that rely on synthetic flavoring must disclose this to consumers.

1. Natural Flavor

This designation refers to flavor components entirely derived from natural sources such as fruits, vegetables, herbs, spices, or animal products. For example, if a product lists “Natural Lemon Flavor,” it means the flavor compounds come directly from lemons. On an ingredient list, it may appear simply as “Natural Flavor.”

 

2. WONF (With Other Natural Flavors)

WONF stands for “With Other Natural Flavors,” and it indicates that the primary flavor comes from the named source, but is blended with other natural ingredients to achieve a fuller, more complex taste. For instance, “Strawberry Flavor WONF” may include natural strawberry compounds along with natural flavors from apple or beet to round out the strawberry profile. WONF flavors are still labeled as natural flavors on ingredient decks.

3. Natural Type Flavor

This category refers to flavors that are naturally derived, but not from the named source. For example, a “Natural Strawberry Type Flavor” may taste like strawberry, but none of the flavor compounds come from actual strawberries. They could be derived from other natural substances that mimic the taste of strawberries. Despite the absence of the actual source fruit, these are still listed as natural flavors on packaging.

4. N&A (Natural & Artificial) Flavor

N&A flavors combine both natural and artificial flavors to achieve a desired taste profile. This allows for cost savings or enhanced stability while still incorporating some natural elements. In ingredient lists, these flavors must be clearly labeled as containing both natural and artificial flavors, which is particularly relevant in artificially flavored products aimed at cutting costs in processed foods.

Why Itaberco Prioritizes Natural Flavors

At Itaberco, our products are crafted using natural flavors, reflecting our dedication to delivering authentic, high-quality dessert solutions. 

Our flavor philosophy centers on quality, consistency, and a strong commitment to clean-label ingredients. This dedication is best illustrated by our work to perfect natural versions of complex flavors, like the challenge of developing a Fior di Panna (a traditional Italian-inspired flavor of sweet cream) from natural sources. It took months of collaboration and tasting to develop this unique profile, but the result was a naturally-derived flavor that met our quality standards—an example of how we continually strive to uphold the integrity of our products through natural means. We apply this same philosophy to color as well, consistently choosing natural color options vs. artificial to maintain the integrity and transparency our customers expect

Common Misconceptions About Artificial and Natural Flavors

When it comes to flavoring, several misconceptions can cloud the conversation. One common belief is that artificial flavors are inherently “bad,” but in reality, they are often chemically identical to their natural counterparts—the key difference lies in their synthetic origin. Similarly, many assume that natural flavors are always healthier, yet both natural and artificial flavors can include additives or carriers that aren’t immediately apparent.

Taste perception also plays a role in these misunderstandings. Highly natural or organic flavors can sometimes have an “earthy” taste, while artificial dessert flavors may come across as overly sweet or synthetic. Understanding these nuances helps clarify that the choice between natural and artificial isn’t always about good versus bad, but about sourcing, application, budget, and the desired sensory experience.

Making the Natural Choice

There’s a place for both natural and artificial ingredients in the broader food landscape. For us, the natural path is the one that most often delivers the experience our customers expect and deserve.

Our passion lies in helping you create desserts and beverages that not only taste extraordinary but feel good to serve. Let’s work together to bring your next idea to life with flavors that stay true to your vision and to nature.

Get Started Today!

 

 

Recent Post